For Release: February 26, 2007
Contact: Office of Public Affairs 603-646-3661

Print Version

Heart Disease Test Utility Questioned

HANOVER, NH—Researchers with Dartmouth Medical School and the Veterans Affairs Outcomes Group at the White River Junction (Vt.) VA Medical Center question the usefulness of the C-Reactive Protein (CRP) test for guiding decisions about cholesterol-lowering medication, saying the test identifies too many at low risk.

Drs. Steven Woloshin and Lisa Schwartz
Drs. Steven Woloshin and
Lisa Schwartz

Adding CRP testing to routine assessments would increase the number of Americans eligible for cholesterol-lowering treatment by about 2 million if used judiciously, and by over 25 million if used broadly - with most of these people being at low risk for heart attacks or cardiovascular disease, the researchers show. They argue that the medical community should focus energies on treating high-risk patients before expanding the pool to include so many low-risk patients. Their study was published in the February Journal of General Internal Medicine.

"There is a push to use this test, and that probably doesn't make much sense," says Dr. Steven Woloshin, an author and associate professor of medicine and of community and family medicine at Dartmouth Medical School (DMS).

According to co-author Dr. Lisa Schwartz, also associate professor of medicine and community and family medicine, "A general population use of the test would identify millions of low-risk people, and we don't know if exposing them to cholesterol medications will do more good than harm. Plus, focusing on low-risk people seems misplaced since over half of high-risk people, who we know are helped by treatment, remain untreated."

Co-authors are Drs. H. Gilbert Welch and Kevin Kerin. Woloshin, Schwartz, and Welch are also part of Dartmouth's Center for Evaluative Clinical Sciences.

For this study, the team analyzed nationally representative data from more than 2,500 people who participated in the 1999-2002 National Health and Nutrition Examination Study (NHANES). They discovered that adding a broadly applied CRP strategy to current cholesterol-based guidelines would make over half the adults age 35 and older in the United States eligible for lipid-lowering therapy.

"Before expanding treatment criteria to include more low-risk patients--for whom treatment benefit is not established--we should ensure the treatment of high-risk patients where the benefit of therapy is clear," says Woloshin.

The authors note that their study has several limitations. Since the NHANES data did not include some cardiovascular risk factors (e.g., presence of an aortic abdominal aneurysm or peripheral artery disease), the number of people in the highest risk groups may be underestimated. Second, not every patient made eligible for cholesterol-lowering therapy by the CRP test will get treated; some will try lifestyle measures first (although data from other studies suggest these measures will only succeed for a minority).


Return to News Archives